1. Home
  2. Learn
  3. Options
  4. Unusual options activity

Options course · Lesson 17 · Agent Forrest

Unusual options activity and why it misleads

Headlines about a giant call bet make it sound like someone knows something. Sometimes they do. More often the tape cannot tell you who bought, who sold, or whether the trade was a bet at all. This lesson shows what a big print can and cannot tell you, with three real MSTR and COIN cases.

9minutesPublished Nov 9, 2026

What is unusual options activity?

Unusual options activity is trading volume in an option contract far above its normal level, often flagged when one trade is very large or volume tops open interest. It shows that someone traded, not who bought, why, or whether the trade opened a new position. A big call print can be a closing sale, a hedge, or one leg of a spread.

What counts as unusual options activity?

Scanners flag unusual options activity when a contract trades far more than its average, when the day's volume tops its open interest, when one order carries a large premium, or when trades fill at the ask. The public tape shows the contract, price, size, time and exchange of each trade.

What it does not show matters more:

  • Who was the buyer and who was the seller. Every contract traded has both. An alert that says calls were bought is describing volume.
  • Whether the trade opened or closed a position. A sell can open a short or close a long; a buy can open a long or close a short. The four actions are covered in buy to open, sell to close.
  • The rest of the trader's book. Shares, other options or futures can turn a scary-looking bet into a hedge.

So a big print is a fact about trading, not a fact about anyone's view.

Was it a new bet or a closing trade?

Open interest is the number of contracts still open. It rises when both sides of a trade are opening, falls when both are closing, and stays flat when one side opens and the other closes, as the position simply passes to a new owner (OIC).

Open interest is not updated during the day. OCC posts it the morning after each session, and the figure stays fixed until the next morning (Options Playbook). That timing creates the main check: compare the day's volume with the change in open interest the next morning.

  • 10,000 contracts trade and open interest rises by about 10,000: most of it opened new positions.
  • 10,000 trade and open interest barely moves, or falls: much of it was closing, passing positions between owners, or opened and closed the same day.

Even a big rise does not say which side opened as the buyer. And the open interest you see during the day reflects the previous session, not today's trades. More on reading volume and open interest is in liquidity, bid-ask and open interest.

Sweeps vs blocks: what do they tell you?

A sweep is a large order split into smaller pieces and filled quickly across several exchanges at the best available prices, so it does not sit partly filled. Because the trader pays for speed, a sweep reads as urgent. A block is a large trade negotiated privately and then reported. Benzinga's explainer is blunt about both: from the order flow, you will not know the trader's strategy, and big traders are not always right (Benzinga).

Where a trade fills offers one more clue. A fill at or above the ask leans buyer-initiated, and a fill at the bid leans seller-initiated. But a buyer who pays the ask might be buying to close a short call in a hurry, which is the opposite of a fresh bullish bet. Urgency tells you someone wanted the trade done now. It does not tell you why.

Hedges and spreads that look like bets

Many large option trades are not standalone bets.

  • Hedges. A fund that is short a stock can buy calls to cap its loss if the stock rips higher. The call purchase looks bullish, and the fund's overall view is bearish.
  • Stock replacement. A holder can sell shares and buy calls to keep upside with less capital at risk. Volume spikes, and the net view barely changes.
  • Covered call selling. Shareholders selling calls against stock create heavy call volume that is neutral to bearish, not bullish. See covered calls and cash-secured puts.
  • Spread legs. Flow feeds often print each leg separately. A vertical spread shows up as one large call buy and one large call sale, and a feed or a headline can pick up only one of them.

The MSTR cases below show the last point in practice.

MSTR: a big sweep and two spreads

June 11, 2025. About $1.8 million in premium went into MSTR $450 calls expiring September 19, 2025, at $36.08 a share, with MSTR at $390.25. The report said most of the premium filled above the ask and called it a highly bullish bet (Nasdaq). Breakeven at expiration was $486.08, about 25% above the price that day. MSTR was near $343 on expiration day (Options Analysis Suite), so any of those calls still held expired worthless. Nobody outside the trade knows whether it opened a position, closed one, or hedged a short stock position that gained as the calls lost.

September 3, 2026. MSTR closed at $144.82, up 17.56%, and two large call trades printed. One was a bull call spread: buy the $136 call, sell the $142 call, expiring the next day, 2,840 contracts each, for about $911,000. The other was a bear call spread: sell the $143 call, buy the $149 call, expiring September 11, 5,000 contracts each, for an $890,000 credit (Tiger Brokers). A feed showing only the 5,000 bought $149 calls would look bullish, yet that leg capped a bearish trade whose maximum loss was about $2.1 million (the $6 width times 500,000 shares, minus the credit). Two big call trades, two opposite views.

COIN: volume four times open interest

June 18, 2025. Coinbase rose about 15.6% to $293.43 during the session, and the $300 calls expiring two days later led the activity. By early afternoon they had traded 29,513 contracts at an average price of $2.72 (Market Chameleon). By the close, volume in that contract reached 65,277, and total COIN options volume was about 942,000 contracts, six times the prior day (Tiger Brokers).

The open interest shown that day was 16,378 contracts, down 1,020 from the day before (Market Chameleon). That change reflects the previous session's trades, not June 18's. What the numbers do say: the day's volume was about four times the open interest at the start of the session, and old holders closing out cannot explain volume that large. Much of it had to be new positions, contracts opened and closed within the day, or both. Which it was, only the next morning's open interest could show.

The headline version, a huge call bet before a rally, skips every step that would tell you whether there was a bet at all.

Does option flow predict stock prices?

Sometimes, but the useful part is not on the public tape. Jun Pan and Allen Poteshman studied Cboe records from 1990 to 2001 that marked each trade by type, including buys that opened new positions. Stocks with a low put-call ratio built from those opening buys beat stocks with a high ratio, on a risk-adjusted basis, by more than 0.40% the next day and more than 1% over the next week. They concluded the signal came mainly from nonpublic information held by option traders (Review of Financial Studies, 2006).

The key detail: a version built only from what the public could see predicted returns for just a day or two, and then prices reversed, a sign of short-term price pressure rather than information (Pan and Poteshman).

Today, opening and closing detail still comes from exchanges as separate paid data. Cboe, for example, sells open-close volume summaries for its exchanges in 10-minute or end-of-day files (Cboe DataShop). The public trade tape that most flow alerts watch reports each trade's price, size and time, not whether it opened or closed a position. To test a print yourself, try the MSTR call simulator and see what move a big call bet would need.

Forrest’s note

When a big print crosses the tape, the first thing I check is the next morning's open interest. Until then, I treat it as a question, not a signal.

Check yourself

1. 20,000 calls trade in one contract today. Tomorrow morning, open interest in that contract is up only 500. What does that suggest?

Most of the volume did not create new positions. It was likely closing trades, positions passing from one owner to another, or contracts opened and closed within the same day. At most a small part of the 20,000 could have been new, and the open interest change still does not tell you whether the new side was a buyer or a seller.

2. A large call order fills above the ask. Name two ways it could be bearish or neutral.

It could be a trader buying to close a short call in a hurry, which ends a bearish position rather than starting a bullish one. It could also be a hedge for a short stock position, or the bought leg of a bear call spread, where the trader sold a lower-strike call at the same time.

3. What did Pan and Poteshman find about the predictive power of option volume that the public could observe?

Their strong signal came from Cboe data that identified buyers opening new positions, which was not publicly observable. A version built from public trade data predicted returns for only a day or two, after which prices reversed. They read that as price pressure, not information, which is why public flow alerts are weak evidence.

Words on this page

Sources